Biofeedback application & effectiveness

The areas of application of biofeedback are almost unlimited due to the diversity of the sensors. This method is primarily used in the fields of psychosomatics, pain therapy, psychology and psychotherapy. However, it is also increasingly being used outside the clinical field, for example to improve performance in sport and at work, as well as in training and coaching.

There are numerous reports from practitioners and extensive scientific literature that prove the effectiveness of biofeedback and neurofeedback. In a review conducted by the US AAPB (Association for Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback) in 2023, many areas of application were classified on a scale from ‘effective and specific’ to ‘possibly effective’.

Source: Khazan, I., Shaffer, F., Moss, D., Lyne, R. & Rosenthal, S. (2023). Evidence-Based practice in biofeedback and neurofeedback.

Effective and specific:

  • Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
  • panic disorders
  • asthma
  • depression
  • Diabetes mellitus
  • Erectile dysfunction
  • Incontinence (adults)
  • Pre-eclampsia

Effective:

  • Headache
  • Chronic back pain
  • High blood pressure
  • Irritable bowel syndrome
  • Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
  • Raynaud’s syndrome
  • Temporomandibular dysfunction (TMD)
  • Cerebral palsy
  • Stroke
  • epilepsy
  • Peak performance
  • Incontinence (children)

Probably effective:

  • Alcohol and drug addiction, among others
  • Fibromyalgia
  • Generalised anxiety disorder (GAS)
  • arthritis
  • autism
  • Tinnitus
  • Chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy
  • Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)
  • Tumour pain
  • Phantom limb pain
  • Coronary heart disease

 

Potentially effective:

  • Specific phobias
  • Chemobrain
  • Functional abdominal pain
  • Hyperhidrosis
  • Vasovagal syncope

Typical areas of application for biofeedback and neurofeedback

Stress & Burnout

Biofeedback is used in the treatment of stress in order to treat it when the symptoms have already become excessive, as well as to prevent such symptoms from occurring in the first place (prevention). From EMG training, breathing training, HRV etc., all the biofeedback modalities mentioned above are actually used here.

Various feedbacks, such as a flower that opens wider and wider, can help the test subjects to relax more and more. Biofeedback is also used as (non-clinical) general relaxation training to actively integrate phases of relaxation into everyday life.

Pain therapy

Alongside stress and burnout, pain therapy is probably the area for which biofeedback is best known. Biofeedback is ideally suited to countering the vicious circle of chronic pain.

EMG biofeedback is usually used here (e.g. for tension headaches, back pain, bruxism). Temperature biofeedback has proven to be helpful in migraine therapy.

Anxiety disorder

Biofeedback is a highly successful technique used for anxiety disorders. Firstly, through general relaxation training, it helps to lower overall arousal levels, which aims to reduce the frequency of anxiety attacks. Additionally, exposure therapy is employed, where clients are exposed to anxiety-inducing stimuli such as images, videos, and other media, enabling them to learn how to cope with these triggers. 

Depression

Biofeedback can support the goals of cognitive and behavioral interventions and help improve self-efficacy or cognitive beliefs.

A study that used, among other things, HRV biofeedback came to the conclusion that biofeedback appears to be a useful adjunctive therapy for the treatment of major depression.

 

Hypertension

The success of treating high blood pressure using biofeedback (HRV and respiratory biofeedback, but also temperature or skin conductance training) can be maintained even after the end of therapy.

In most cases, medications can be reduced or even stopped completely (here again, all medication-related decisions should only be made in consultation with doctors).

 

Rehabilitation

Often (e.g. after a stroke) the residual activity of the muscle is so weak that the test subject can hardly or not notice it at all. Muscle building during the rehabilitation of these muscles is often slow. This combination of effort and barely visible success often leads to low client motivation. Biofeedback can help maintain motivation because even the smallest training successes are reported back and the test subject therefore notices their progress.

Biofeedback can improve, accelerate or support the rehabilitation of peripheral and central paralysis compared to conventional physical training.

ADHD

The goal of treating ADHD with neurofeedback is to train the brain’s frequency bands so that the beta band (representing attention) is activated more and the theta band (representing daydreaming) is reduced.

The child practices learning this skill using EEG electrodes attached to the head and child-friendly feedback (cartoons, fairy tales). The success of neurofeedback for ADHD sometimes even exceeds that of drug treatment or is comparable to it (however, drug-related questions should always be clarified with a doctor in advance).

Professional sports

Just as in professional life, biofeedback and neurofeedback can also be used to optimize performance in sports.

The methods have already been used, for example, by Olympic athletes, golfers and other athletes.

Irritable bowel syndrome

HRV biofeedback in particular is considered a very successful method for treating irritable bowel syndrome. Studies reported freedom from symptoms in almost 70% of participants, with the rest experiencing at least some relief.

PTSD

Respiratory biofeedback in particular is very popular in the treatment of PTSD. It can be used in addition to cognitive behavioral therapy. This procedure is easy to supplement and is considered a practical method with high effectiveness.

Asthma

Treating asthma with biofeedback leads to improvement in two ways. On the one hand, the clients learn to reduce the fear of the threat of an asthma attack, and on the other hand, they also see improvements in breathing parameters (especially forced expiratory volume).

Tinnitus

Chronic tinnitus often shows increased levels of stress and tension. Biofeedback is then used to influence these parameters, e.g. the tension in the jaw area. However, the aspect of showing clients the psycho-physiological connections to the illness is also very useful.

This form of treatment is well accepted, has no side effects and leads to a significant reduction in tinnitus distress.

Constipation

To treat constipation using biofeedback, for example, anal probes and EMG biofeedback are used. Some studies have found this biofeedback-based approach to be superior to other methods.

Erectile dysfunction

The treatment of erectile dysfunction using biofeedback takes place in two ways. On the one hand, impaired pelvic floor muscles can be the reason for the symptoms. In this case, this area is trained using anal electrodes.

In the case of psychogenic dysfunction, relaxation training can be helpful in reducing the subject’s stress level.

Stress diagnostics

Biofeedback is also used to assess a client’s individual stress and recovery profile. This is actually a central component of biofeedback therapy, as this profile is usually the starting point for further action.

What is exciting is not only the client’s reaction to various stressors (such as mental arithmetic), but also how well they can recover in subsequent relaxation phases.

Sleeping disorder

When treating sleep disorders with biofeedback, a type of “sleep protocol” is usually learned. This can consist of various elements from the spectrum of biofeedback and neurofeedback (muscle relaxation, temperature training, neurofeedback…).

Once the client has practiced this protocol diligently, they can use it at home at bedtime to help them fall asleep faster.

Profession

Biofeedback can also be used in non-clinical areas such as: B. company health care or the achievement of top professional performance. These areas have become increasingly popular in recent years.

Incontinence

Biofeedback training for incontinence is quite similar to work in rehabilitation. The pelvic nodes are trained directly using vaginal and anal electrodes. The treatment shows success rates of almost 80% and is also suitable for the treatment of sexual disorders.

Raynaud's disease

Raynaud’s disease is often colloquially referred to as white finger disease. Those affected often suffer from cold feet or hands. The method of choice here is temperature training, by means of which clients learn to warm these areas voluntarily. The literature reports lengths of between 5-10 sessions (individual people between 8-16 or more) to learn to warm the hands. Whilst training is initially carried out under relaxation conditions, the training can later be increased by applying cold stimuli.